American Eagle Outfitters, Inc. will announce its results for the first quarter of fiscal 2025 on May 29. The company expects revenue to be $1.1 billion, a 4.6% decrease from last year. Analysts predict a loss of 25 cents per share, a significant drop from last year’s earnings of 34 cents per share. In the last quarter, American Eagle’s earnings were 8% higher than expected. However, this quarter is not projected to follow suit. Ongoing inflation and high debt levels are influencing consumer spending, especially affecting American Eagle’s core customers who are cutting back on non-essential purchases like clothing. In a recent update, the company noted disappointing preliminary results for the first quarter. Problems with their merchandising approach led to higher promotions and inventory issues. As a result, they took an inventory write-down of nearly $75 million on spring and summer products. Revenue is still expected at $1.1 billion, with comparable sales projected to drop by almost 3%. Despite these challenges, American Eagle is committed to its long-term growth strategy called Powering Profitable Growth. The company’s shares are currently trading at a low price-to-earnings ratio of 9.4X. Over the past six months, their stock has fallen by 42.4%, while the industry average drop is only 10.7%. The financial situation is concerning. A 4.6% decrease in revenue compared to last year, along with a shift from profit to predicted losses, raises alarms. The company’s preliminary results indicated weaknesses in merchandising, which led to unexpected discounts and a significant inventory write-down. Predicted comparable sales will likely decline 3%. While this might not alarm many retailers, it indicates less interest from shoppers both in stores and online. Broader economic challenges, like persistent inflation and higher household debt, are putting additional pressure on the company, especially as younger customers face tighter budgets. From an analysis perspective, last quarter’s slight success does not provide much reassurance now. Although there was an 8% increase in earnings, the market does not expect this to happen again due to weakening apparel demand and markdowns that hurt profit margins. The company’s valuation suggests that expectations are low. The forward price-to-earnings ratio of 9.4X reflects slower growth, lower pricing power, and execution risks. In the past six months, the stock has dropped significantly—about four times more than the sector average. This indicates that the market views American Eagle not just as part of a retail slump, but as a company facing unique challenges. Looking ahead, the Powering Profitable Growth strategy is optimistic, but current signals urge caution. Issues with spring and summer products suggest there are problems with planning and response times. Seasonal changes are opportunities for full-price sales, and when those fail, margins suffer. Questions to consider include whether operational changes are already happening and how quickly they are being executed. Management has shown awareness of these issues through early disclosures, which is positive. However, until there is clear evidence of balanced inventory and reduced margin pressure, the short-term outlook remains uncertain. As we approach earnings season, market dynamics may shift. With rising volatility and competitors managing their inventories better, the upcoming weeks are a chance to reassess positions. If the company’s guidance worsens or if there are ongoing logistical issues during earnings calls, the stock may face further declines. Conversely, if results are better than expected or early success from the new strategy is evident, the current low valuation could prompt a strong market reaction. Option premiums indicate uncertainty, with spread differences widening a bit more on near-term puts than on calls, suggesting some long position holders are hedging. The direction of bets around the May 29 report will depend on the clarity and tone of the results. While revenue misses may already be factored in, discussions on margins and future guidance could significantly shift market sentiment.

here to set up a live account on VT Markets now