The recent Non-Farm Payrolls (NFP) report caused the Federal Reserve (Fed) to quickly change its approach, showing it is hesitant to overlook weaknesses in the labor market. Following the weaker data, the market now anticipates 60 basis points of rate cuts by the end of the year, up from 35 basis points before the report. Several Fed members, including those from New York, San Francisco, and Minneapolis, have expressed support for a potential rate cut due to concerns about the labor market. Before this, Fed officials balanced labor market issues with the need for price stability, aiming to maintain a 2% inflation target. However, the disappointing NFP report led to a swift shift in their stance.

Potential Policy Error

The market tends to react to single data points, but the Fed’s response could risk a policy mistake, especially if labor market conditions stabilize and the economy recovers. This change could be supported by tariff resolutions that promote hiring and investment. Currently, the job market is characterized by low firing and low hiring rates, along with high inflation pressures as indicated by PMI surveys. Upcoming jobless claims and Consumer Price Index (CPI) data could change expectations. If the Fed continues its dovish tone despite potentially stronger data, it may signal market worries about a Fed miscalculation, shown by rising Treasury yields contrary to some leadership views. The Fed’s reaction seems like an overreaction after just one report. The July 2025 NFP numbers were softer than expected, adding only 155,000 jobs. In response, Fed officials quickly hinted at a rate cut for September, leading the markets to now price in 60 basis points of cuts by year-end, up from 35 basis points just a week ago. This abrupt reaction may lead to a policy mistake. While the Fed focuses on labor weaknesses, Core CPI remains high at 2.9% year-over-year, much closer to 3% than the Fed’s target of 2%. A single weak jobs report does not eliminate the persistent inflation pressures highlighted by PMI surveys over recent months. Also, the tariff uncertainty from 2024 froze hiring and investment. With this uncertainty now cleared, businesses may be ready to expand, especially if borrowing costs decrease. If the Fed cuts rates while the economy rebounds, it risks igniting inflation once again.

Opportunity for Traders

This scenario creates a chance for derivative traders to prepare for increased volatility. The market is leaning heavily toward rate cuts, yet the underlying data is mixed, with today’s jobless claims and the important CPI report next week. Options strategies, like straddles on equity indices or interest rate futures, could profit from sharp moves in either direction. Keep an eye on the 10-year Treasury yield. If the Fed continues to sound dovish even if next week’s CPI is high, watch for a rise in the yield. An increasing yield alongside discussions of rate cuts could signal market concerns about the Fed making an inflationary error, reminiscent of the “transitory” misjudgment from 2021. Given the market’s expectation for dovish policies, the risk leans toward a hawkish surprise. Should today’s jobless claims or next week’s inflation data come in strong, the market could quickly and violently adjust. Traders might consider positioning for this scenario through options on SOFR futures or buying puts on long-duration Treasury bond ETFs. Create your live VT Markets account and start trading now.

here to set up a live account on VT Markets now