The growth of the US workforce has nearly come to a halt without immigration. This situation presents challenges for economic growth. A stagnant workforce means that GDP growth must depend on improving productivity instead of bringing in new workers. The economy can only grow if productivity increases through innovation or new technology. If productivity doesn’t improve, GDP can stall since there aren’t enough workers to produce goods and services. Over time, a stable or declining workforce must support more retirees, which increases financial pressure. While a tighter labor supply may raise wages, the economy as a whole may grow more slowly. Therefore, improving productivity is crucial to keep the economy moving forward.

Impact on Various Industries

Immigrants are essential in many sectors, including both high-skill and vital jobs. Without them, we may see shortages in industries such as agriculture, construction, healthcare, hospitality, manufacturing, and technology. These sectors might face labor shortages, higher costs, and reduced output. For instance, the agriculture industry heavily relies on immigrant workers, which could lead to higher food prices if they are not available. In healthcare, an aging population is increasing demand, leading to even more staffing challenges. The hospitality industry might see business closures or less service, while technology sectors rely on immigrant talent for innovation. Recent comments from the Federal Reserve show that US workforce growth is nearly zero without immigration. This could increase market volatility and make GDP growth heavily reliant on productivity gains, which aren’t guaranteed. Any news related to immigration policy or labor participation rates is likely to create sharp shifts in the market. This environment makes options betting on volatility, such as VIX call options, a potential consideration. We’ve seen similar situations after the COVID-19 labor shortages of 2021 and 2022, which led to persistent inflation. As a result, the market might begin to consider the risk that inflation won’t drop as expected, potentially forcing the Federal Reserve to postpone rate cuts or remain cautious. This scenario suggests that traders might consider options on treasury ETFs like TLT to prepare for changes in interest rate expectations.

Investment Strategies and Market Implications

The analysis highlights industries most affected by labor shortages, including construction, hospitality, and agriculture. The July 2025 jobs report indicated increasing wage pressures in these areas, showing that companies are raising salaries to attract limited workers. It might be wise to buy put options on specific sector ETFs, like the homebuilders ETF (XHB) or the leisure and entertainment ETF (PEJ), to protect against falling profit margins. On the other hand, the only way out of this economic slowdown is a boost in productivity. This situation highlights companies focused on automation, robotics, and artificial intelligence. As businesses seek to improve efficiency due to worker shortages, the technology sector could outperform. Thus, buying call options on automation-focused ETFs could be a strong long-term strategy. Everyone will be watching the upcoming reports on productivity and labor costs for the third quarter of 2025. Last quarter’s productivity growth of just 0.7% in Q2 2025 was disappointing and far below what is necessary for sustainable economic growth in a low workforce growth environment. Any further weakness in these reports could signal economic stagnation, creating challenges for the overall market indices. Create your live VT Markets account and start trading now.

here to set up a live account on VT Markets now