In September, the University of Michigan’s preliminary consumer sentiment index was 55.4. This is below the expected 58.0 and down from the previous 58.2. Current conditions showed little change, standing at 61.2, just shy of the expected 61.3, and down from 61.7 before. Expectations fell to 51.8, missing the forecast of 54.9 and lower than the prior 55.9. Inflation expectations for the next year stayed at 4.8%, unchanged from earlier data. However, the five-year forecast increased to 3.9%, up from 3.5% previously.

Survey and Inflation

This survey was once highly respected but has faced criticism over perceived political bias. The Federal Reserve watches it closely, especially due to shifts in inflation expectations. A previous rise in inflation forecasts led to a rate hike, but later adjustments lessened its significance. After this report, the US dollar weakened, although it still shows some resistance despite the report’s implications. The drop in consumer sentiment to 55.4 is a concerning alert, but the details signal more trouble for the Federal Reserve. While current conditions remain steady, the fall in expectations to 51.8 suggests consumers are preparing for challenges ahead. The rise in five-year inflation expectations to 3.9% complicates things for policymakers trying to support a weakening economy while controlling inflation. We’ve seen similar situations before, and they often end poorly for markets. In mid-2022, a spike in this survey’s inflation component spooked the Fed into an unexpected 75-basis-point rate hike, even though later data revisions showed the impact wasn’t as severe. Although this survey may seem like more noise than valuable information, the Fed has reacted intensely to it before, making its next decision highly uncertain.

Market Reactions

This report adds to an already confusing economic outlook, especially after the August 2025 jobs report showed an uptick in the unemployment rate to 4.1%. At the same time, core inflation remains high at 3.2%. The combination of slowing growth and persistent inflation raises concerns about potential policy mistakes. The risk is that the Fed either tightens too much during a recession or allows inflation expectations to spiral out of control. For traders, the increasing uncertainty suggests that buying volatility may be the best strategy for the next few weeks. Options on major indices, like puts on the S&P 500, could serve as an effective hedge against a surprise in federal policy or further economic slowdowns. The VIX, hovering around 19, indicates a strong case for preparing for volatility as the market processes this mixed information. The Fed funds futures market is likely to see notable activity as traders reassess the chances of a rate hike at the next meeting. While a pause is still the main expectation, this report introduces enough doubt to make short-term interest rate derivatives especially volatile. Keep an eye on shifts in probabilities for the November FOMC meeting, as any hawkish comments from Fed officials soon could lead to rapid adjustments. The initial weakness of the US dollar due to poor sentiment data could be temporary. If the market begins to focus more on rising inflation expectations, worries about a more aggressive Fed could quickly bring buyers back to the dollar. This suggests that betting against the dollar is risky and that equity markets may struggle until there is more clarity from the Fed. Create your live VT Markets account and start trading now.

here to set up a live account on VT Markets now