BP reported underlying profits of $2.35 billion for the second quarter, which beat expectations, but was down from last year’s $2.75 billion. A rise in divestments to $1.35 billion helped improve performance. On a replacement cost basis, profits bounced back from a $16 million loss last year, exceeding $2 billion. Operating cash flow fell to $6.27 billion from $8.1 billion, even as BP made $1.7 billion in cost savings compared to its 2023 baseline. A recent discovery in Brazil strengthens BP’s focus on oil and gas, but shareholder reactions to the Q2 results seem inconsistent with the financial performance.

Shareholder Returns

BP announced a $750 million share buyback and a 4% increase in dividends, rising to 8.32 cents per share, enhancing returns for shareholders. Net debt dropped slightly from Q1 but remains $3.5 billion higher than last year, now just over $26 billion. BP aims to lower net debt to between $14 billion and $18 billion by 2027 while increasing dividends by 4% each year, targeting total distributions to shareholders of 30% to 40% of operating cash flow. Achieving these goals relies on cash flow from new assets in Brazil and improved efficiency. CEO Murray Auchincloss and incoming chair Albert Manifold will assess BP’s business portfolio starting September 1, 2025, as they strive to meet these ambitious targets.

Market Reaction and Strategy

As of early August 2025, the mixed signals from BP’s results create a clear opportunity. While profits exceeded forecasts, the market is concerned about the sharp decline in operating cash flow. This gap between reported profits and actual cash generation is where we should concentrate our focus. The upcoming business review on September 1 is a crucial event that could introduce market uncertainty. This anticipation is already reflected in the options market, where implied volatility for September 2025 contracts has risen to 34%. That’s a significant premium compared to the stock’s historical volatility of 26%. This indicates that traders expect a notable price change following the review. For those optimistic about BP’s future, buying call options might be a smart move based on the company’s robust shareholder returns. With Brent crude prices remaining above $85 through July, the consistent dividend increases and share buybacks could lead to a stock re-rating if the review signals a positive direction. This suggests the market may be overly pessimistic. On the other hand, the bearish perspective focuses on the weak cash flow and growing debt. Competitors like Shell recently reported better cash metrics, which raises concerns. The nearly 15% increase in net debt year-over-year poses risks to future growth. Purchasing put options could be a strategy to speculate that the September review might uncover deeper problems or necessitate a costly strategic shift. We approach this situation mindful of the significant strategic changes BP made in the early 2020s. This upcoming review by a new CEO and chair is another pivotal moment that could change the company’s direction. Thus, strategies that benefit from increased volatility, like long straddles, might be wise for traders anticipating a big price move—though the direction remains uncertain. Create your live VT Markets account and start trading now.

here to set up a live account on VT Markets now