Concerns are rising about the dismissal of Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) Commissioner Erika McEntarfer by the Trump administration. Many fear this could be an attempt to undermine the credibility of official inflation data, which in turn could influence markets and debates over Federal Reserve policy. The main concern is the possible manipulation or discrediting of the Consumer Price Index (CPI). The trustworthiness of the $2.1 trillion market for Treasury Inflation-Protected Securities (TIPS) heavily relies on the CPI’s accuracy. If trust wanes, investors may demand a higher risk premium.

Market Implications

Analysts warn that the reliability of market-implied inflation breakevens could be at risk. These breakevens, which compare nominal Treasuries and TIPS, are crucial for making informed monetary policy decisions. If people start viewing CPI data as politically influenced, it may create uncertainty in the TIPS market. This uncertainty could weaken the impact of market-implied inflation expectations. There is growing concern that inflation statistics may be swayed by politics, which could harm the long-term credibility of U.S. financial markets. Such a situation threatens stability and reliability, affecting both policy discussions and financial markets. After the recent dismissal of the BLS Commissioner, we must now consider the possibility of political influence on U.S. inflation data. This adds a new layer of uncertainty that our models do not factor in. The major question is whether we can still trust the Consumer Price Index (CPI) as a reliable benchmark for trading. The effects are already noticeable in the $2.1 trillion market for TIPS. Recently, the 5-year breakeven inflation rate dropped from 2.4% to 2.1%, even as rising import prices indicate persistent inflation. This decline suggests investors are seeking a higher risk premium for holding TIPS, worried that the CPI data may not be trustworthy. For derivative traders, this means that inflation swaps linked to the CPI carry greater risk. The value of these contracts is tied to the integrity of the index, which is now being questioned. We need to start factoring in a potential “data integrity” premium, especially for longer-term instruments.

Impact on Financial Markets

Expect increased volatility in the coming weeks. The implied volatility on CPI options has surged nearly 30% since mid-July 2025, signaling that the market anticipates more unpredictable inflation reports. This indicates a shift towards buying options, such as CPI caps and floors, to safeguard against extreme outcomes influenced by politics rather than just speculating on direction. We can look at historical examples like Argentina, where inflation statistics were manipulated from 2007 to 2015. During that time, official data strayed from reality, eroding market trust for nearly a decade. This history highlights the significant credibility risks facing U.S. markets if similar actions are taken. The Federal Reserve’s response to this situation adds another layer of complexity. If the Fed begins to downplay the CPI and focus more on other measures like the Personal Consumption Expenditures (PCE) price index, the long-standing connection between inflation data and monetary policy could weaken. This change would make it more difficult to anticipate the Fed’s interest rate decisions based solely on CPI reports. Create your live VT Markets account and start trading now.

here to set up a live account on VT Markets now